Tiered LDAP groups

This commit is contained in:
2026-10-29 14:24:47 -04:00
parent 4c1174df19
commit a56eec0b1c
9 changed files with 142 additions and 2 deletions
+92
View File
@@ -99,6 +99,44 @@ the application. Level 0 is the free account baseline; paid offers are levels
groupOfUniqueNames groups, sentinel and ACLs separately. Override group DNs if
needed; sandbox testing requires separate test-mode prices.
### Service access groups, including free Level 0
Set `www_membership_service_groups` to a mapping of **quoted effective level**
keys to lists of pre-created LDAP group DNs. The default `{}` grants no additional
groups. For example:
```yaml
www_membership_service_groups:
"0": ["cn=community-chat,ou=membership-services,dc=example,dc=org"]
"1": ["cn=community-chat,ou=membership-services,dc=example,dc=org"]
"2":
- "cn=community-chat,ou=membership-services,dc=example,dc=org"
- "cn=game-servers,ou=membership-services,dc=example,dc=org"
```
The highest valid paid membership selects exactly that level's list. **No implicit
inheritance**: include groups again for levels 3–5 if they should also receive
them. Level 0 is selected only when no paid entitlement remains; repeat a free
service DN at every level to offer it to all members. Original tier `group_dn`
grants are unchanged and independent of these additional service groups.
The role serializes the mapping into the existing membership-tiers ConfigMap as
`service-groups.json`, sets `MEMBERSHIP_SERVICE_GROUPS_FILE`, and includes it in
the configuration revision so updates trigger workload rollout. Do not override
it using `MEMBERSHIP_SERVICE_GROUPS_JSON` in the public environment. Publish an
updated membership image before deploying this role change; no new DB migration
is needed. See [tests/example-vars.yml](tests/example-vars.yml) for all six levels.
Targets must be dedicated `groupOfUniqueNames` groups with the existing sentinel;
provision groups and narrow `uniqueMember` worker ACLs separately. Configure each
service/Dex to authorize those groups. Never map admin/staff or independently
managed groups: the worker **removes noneligible local members**, including
manually granted memberships. Keep retired groups/ACLs until revocation completes.
Historical group targets persist for safe removal after mappings change. Expiry
returns users to level 0 without waiting for Stripe/SHKeeper, but LDAP outages
and downstream cached sessions can still delay access changes. Free grants cover
local membership accounts, not untouched users elsewhere in LDAP.
### Secrets
Create an Opaque Secret using External Secrets, Sealed Secrets or your secret
@@ -124,12 +162,66 @@ Do not use root/admin LDAP credentials. Restrict ACLs to the website account OU
and dedicated group attributes. Use SHKeeper's invoice API key, never wallet
private keys or UI/payout credentials.
`LDAP_BIND_DN` names the membership service account; `LDAP_BIND_PASSWORD` must
be its original plaintext password, **not** its stored LDAP `userPassword` hash
or an already-base64-encoded value. Supply original values in
`www_membership_secret_data`; the role base64-encodes them once for Secret `data`.
Current membership login uses verified Dex issuer/subject claims without an LDAP
connection. These service credentials remain required for account registration
and worker group synchronization. Older images logging
`LDAP service bind rejected during Dex callback` or
`Dex callback rejected kind=LDAPInvalidCredentialsResult` still perform the
retired callback lookup; upgrade the membership image to remove that dependency.
Fix service credentials separately for registration/sync, then rerun the role to
roll out web and worker. Do not use directory administrator credentials.
`LDAP_PASSWORD_SCHEME` gates new registrations only; it does not select the hash
algorithm for existing-user login.
The Dex-only login release adds migration `0004_dex_login_identity`. Keep
`DEX_ISSUER` unchanged during this upgrade so existing subjects are pinned to
their original issuer, and coordinate replacing web/worker together. Existing
subject bindings and billing data are retained. Unbound local accounts require
proof from their recent registration session or an administrator's explicit
`bind_dex_identity` mapping (`--account`, `--uid`, `--subject`); they are never
claimed by email/username matching alone. Review any retired connector bindings
before deployment. Keep Dex's existing connector/uid mapping unchanged and do not
recycle usernames. The worker pins new users' directory UUIDs separately; LDAP
outages can still delay paid group grants/revocations even though login works.
Private trust roots belong in a separate CA Secret. Set paths such as
`LDAP_CA_CERT_FILE`, `SHKEEPER_CA_CERT_FILE`, `PGSSLROOTCERT` or
`REQUESTS_CA_BUNDLE` to `/etc/membership/ca/<secret-key>`. The read-only mount is
shared by web, worker and migrations. Verify certificate expiry, strong keys,
SHA-2 signatures and trust independently; do not disable TLS verification.
### Self-service profiles
The profile release requires a membership image with Pillow and migration
`0005_profile_email_change`, plus the updated website templates/CSS. The role's
migration Job still runs before workloads. Deploy matching reviewed versions of
the application and website; do not reuse cached image tags.
The membership page links to an authenticated editor with friendly labels for
the requested inetOrgPerson attributes, with `displayName` labelled **Gamer tag**.
Dex's normal claims do not contain the full profile; opening the editor reads
the current LDAP entry, while ordinary sign-in remains LDAP-independent. The
service identity needs read/search access to profile attributes and operational
UUID/timestamp fields. Writes use the member's current password and **user bind**,
not broader service privileges. Configure narrow self-write ACLs, server-side
mail/uid uniqueness and RFC 4528 assertion support. SSH key edits additionally
require the `ldapPublicKey` schema and pre-added auxiliary class or an ACL allowing
only that specific self-add. This role does not create schema/ACLs automatically.
Email changes require mailbox verification plus the current password and replace
all existing mail values. Password hashing is delegated to slapd's Password Modify
policy; the application does not generate MD5-Crypt or expose stored hashes.
Review legacy hashing separately. See the application's self-service profile
documentation for the full attribute mapping and directory prerequisites.
The ingress upload limit is 2 MiB to accommodate a 1 MiB JPEG and multipart
overhead. Apache retains 256 KiB for non-profile member routes. Keep access/body
logging disabled for verification URLs, passwords and other profile data.
### Example inventory and hostname
[tests/example-vars.yml](tests/example-vars.yml) contains public configuration
+8
View File
@@ -55,12 +55,18 @@ www_membership_stripe_enabled: false
www_membership_shkeeper_enabled: false
www_membership_environment_overrides: {}
# Explicit effective membership level -> service group DNs. No inheritance.
# Include a group at each level that should receive it; level 0 is free-only.
# Only dedicate groups whose entire membership may be managed by this service.
www_membership_service_groups: {}
# Public settings only. Credentials belong in the membership Secret.
www_membership_environment:
MEMBERSHIP_PUBLIC_URL: "https://{{ www_hostname }}"
MEMBERSHIP_ALLOW_HTTP: "0"
MEMBERSHIP_TRUST_PROXY: "1"
MEMBERSHIP_TIERS_FILE: /etc/membership/tiers/tiers.json
MEMBERSHIP_SERVICE_GROUPS_FILE: /etc/membership/tiers/service-groups.json
POSTGRES_HOST: membership-db
POSTGRES_PORT: "5432"
POSTGRES_DB: membership
@@ -71,6 +77,8 @@ www_membership_environment:
DEX_CONNECTOR_ID: ldap
LDAP_URL: ldaps://ldap.example.com
LDAP_ALLOW_INSECURE: "0"
# Used only for registration/group sync, not Dex login callbacks.
# Its plaintext bind password belongs in Secret LDAP_BIND_PASSWORD, not here.
LDAP_BIND_DN: ""
LDAP_ACCOUNT_BASE_DN: ou=www,ou=people,dc=example,dc=com
LDAP_SEARCH_BASE_DN: ou=people,dc=example,dc=com
+15 -1
View File
@@ -13,10 +13,13 @@
- "www_membership_image is search('(:[^/]+$|@sha256:[a-f0-9]{64}$)')"
- www_membership_environment is mapping
- www_membership_tiers is mapping
- www_membership_service_groups is mapping
- www_membership_environment.MEMBERSHIP_PUBLIC_URL == 'https://' ~ www_hostname
- www_membership_environment.MEMBERSHIP_ALLOW_HTTP | string == '0'
- www_membership_environment.MEMBERSHIP_TRUST_PROXY | string == '1'
- www_membership_environment.MEMBERSHIP_TIERS_FILE == '/etc/membership/tiers/tiers.json'
- www_membership_environment.MEMBERSHIP_SERVICE_GROUPS_FILE == '/etc/membership/tiers/service-groups.json'
- "'MEMBERSHIP_SERVICE_GROUPS_JSON' not in www_membership_environment"
- "'MEMBERSHIP_SQLITE_PATH' not in www_membership_environment"
- "'MEMBERSHIP_TIERS_JSON' not in www_membership_environment"
- www_membership_replicas | int >= 1
@@ -36,6 +39,17 @@
- not www_membership_postgres_managed or www_membership_environment.POSTGRES_PORT | string == '5432'
fail_msg: Supply a versioned membership image and configure verified LDAP, SMTP, Dex, database and payment settings (see role README).
- name: Validate service group level mappings
tags: [membership_validate]
ansible.builtin.assert:
that:
- item.key | string is match('^(0|[1-9][0-9]*)$')
- item.key | string in (['0'] + (www_membership_tiers.values() | map(attribute='level') | map('string') | list))
- item.value is sequence and item.value is not string and item.value is not mapping
- item.value | select('string') | list | length == item.value | length
fail_msg: Service groups must map explicit configured levels (including 0) to lists of LDAP group DNs.
loop: "{{ www_membership_service_groups | dict2items }}"
- name: Validate optional CA file mount paths
tags: [membership_validate]
ansible.builtin.assert:
@@ -137,7 +151,7 @@
- name: Compute configuration revision without secret contents
# resourceVersion changes trigger a rollout without exposing secret values.
ansible.builtin.set_fact:
_www_membership_revision: "{{ {'image': www_membership_image, 'environment': www_membership_environment, 'tiers': www_membership_tiers, 'secret_name': www_membership_secret_name, 'secret_version': (_www_membership_secret.resources[0].metadata.resourceVersion if not ansible_check_mode else 'check'), 'ca_name': www_membership_ca_secret_name, 'ca_version': (_www_membership_ca.resources[0].metadata.resourceVersion if www_membership_ca_secret_name | length > 0 and not ansible_check_mode else ''), 'rollout': www_rollout_revision} | to_json(sort_keys=True) | hash('sha256') }}"
_www_membership_revision: "{{ {'image': www_membership_image, 'environment': www_membership_environment, 'tiers': www_membership_tiers, 'service_groups': www_membership_service_groups, 'secret_name': www_membership_secret_name, 'secret_version': (_www_membership_secret.resources[0].metadata.resourceVersion if not ansible_check_mode else 'check'), 'ca_name': www_membership_ca_secret_name, 'ca_version': (_www_membership_ca.resources[0].metadata.resourceVersion if www_membership_ca_secret_name | length > 0 and not ansible_check_mode else ''), 'rollout': www_rollout_revision} | to_json(sort_keys=True) | hash('sha256') }}"
no_log: true
- name: Deploy public membership configuration and network isolation
+1
View File
@@ -15,6 +15,7 @@ metadata:
namespace: {{ www_namespace }}
data:
tiers.json: {{ www_membership_tiers | to_json | to_json }}
service-groups.json: {{ www_membership_service_groups | to_json | to_json }}
---
# Only Apache may assert the trusted proxy headers to the membership service.
# Requires a CNI which actually enforces NetworkPolicy.
+4
View File
@@ -14,6 +14,10 @@ ProxyPassReverse "/members/" "http://membership:8000/members/"
Require all denied
</If>
</Location>
<Location "/members/profile/">
# Bounded JPEG upload plus multipart overhead; other routes remain 256 KiB.
LimitRequestBody 2097152
</Location>
{% else %}
# Membership proxy disabled. Existing stateful workloads are not deleted.
<Location "/members/">
+2 -1
View File
@@ -152,7 +152,8 @@ metadata:
# Redact email verification tokens and OIDC codes at the edge, not only in
# Apache/Gunicorn. Do not enable request-body/error tracing for /members/.
nginx.ingress.kubernetes.io/enable-access-log: "false"
nginx.ingress.kubernetes.io/proxy-body-size: "256k"
# Apache retains 256 KiB for non-profile member routes.
nginx.ingress.kubernetes.io/proxy-body-size: "2m"
nginx.ingress.kubernetes.io/proxy-read-timeout: "120"
spec:
ingressClassName: {{ www_ingress_class }}
+9
View File
@@ -4,6 +4,15 @@ www_hostname: www.eom.dev
www_membership_image: registry.example.org/www-membership:2026-10-23
www_repo_version: refs/heads/main
www_membership_secret_name: www-membership-credentials
# Examples only: create dedicated groupOfUniqueNames entries and ACLs first.
# No automatic inheritance: include each group at every permitted level.
www_membership_service_groups:
"0": ["cn=community-chat,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev"]
"1": ["cn=community-chat,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev"]
"2": ["cn=community-chat,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev", "cn=game-servers,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev"]
"3": ["cn=community-chat,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev", "cn=game-servers,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev"]
"4": ["cn=community-chat,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev", "cn=game-servers,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev"]
"5": ["cn=community-chat,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev", "cn=game-servers,ou=membership-services,dc=eom,dc=dev"]
www_membership_shkeeper_enabled: true
www_membership_environment_overrides:
# Optional plaintext LDAP for a trusted cluster only; sends passwords unencrypted.
+3
View File
@@ -11,6 +11,9 @@
- name: Supply nonsecret fixture settings
ansible.builtin.set_fact:
www_membership_image: registry.example.org/www-membership:release-test
www_membership_service_groups:
"0": ["cn=free-service,ou=groups,dc=example,dc=org"]
"2": ["cn=paid-service,ou=groups,dc=example,dc=org", "cn=second-service,ou=groups,dc=example,dc=org"]
_www_membership_revision: aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
www_membership_environment: "{{ www_membership_environment | combine({'MEMBERSHIP_PUBLIC_URL': 'https://' ~ www_hostname, 'LDAP_BIND_DN': 'cn=membership,dc=example,dc=org', 'LDAP_PASSWORD_SCHEME': '{ARGON2}', 'EMAIL_HOST': 'smtp.example.org', 'STRIPE_PORTAL_CONFIGURATION': 'bpc_test'}) }}"
- name: Render Apache proxy fixture
+8
View File
@@ -51,6 +51,10 @@ assert plaintext_config["LDAP_URL"] == "ldap://openldap.openldap.svc.cluster.loc
assert all(isinstance(value, str) for value in plaintext_config.values())
assert "MEMBERSHIP_SECRET_KEY" not in config and "SHKEEPER_API_KEY" not in config
tiers = json.loads(find(all_objects, "ConfigMap", "membership-tiers")["data"]["tiers.json"])
service_groups = json.loads(find(all_objects, "ConfigMap", "membership-tiers")["data"]["service-groups.json"])
assert config["MEMBERSHIP_SERVICE_GROUPS_FILE"] == "/etc/membership/tiers/service-groups.json"
assert service_groups["0"] == ["cn=free-service,ou=groups,dc=example,dc=org"]
assert len(service_groups["2"]) == 2
assert len(tiers) == 5 and tiers["level-5"]["usd_amount"] == "64.00"
assert [tiers[f"level-{level}"]["level"] for level in range(1, 6)] == list(range(1, 6))
for name in ["membership", "membership-worker"]:
@@ -76,6 +80,9 @@ apache = find(all_objects, "ConfigMap", "httpd")["data"]
assert "http://membership:8000/members/" in apache["membership.conf"]
assert "X-Forwarded-Proto" in apache["membership.conf"]
assert "Require all denied" in apache["membership.conf"]
assert "LimitRequestBody 262144" in apache["membership.conf"]
assert '<Location "/members/profile/">' in apache["membership.conf"]
assert "LimitRequestBody 2097152" in apache["membership.conf"]
assert "env=!membership_sensitive" in apache["httpd.conf"]
assert "LoadModule proxy_http_module" in apache["httpd.conf"]
source = find(all_objects, "Deployment", "httpd")["spec"]["template"]["spec"]["initContainers"][0]
@@ -83,6 +90,7 @@ assert "rm -rf" not in source["command"][-1]
assert 'cp -a /tmp/www/htdocs/. /data/' in source["command"][-1]
ingress = find(all_objects, "Ingress", "www")
assert ingress["metadata"]["annotations"]["nginx.ingress.kubernetes.io/enable-access-log"] == "false"
assert ingress["metadata"]["annotations"]["nginx.ingress.kubernetes.io/proxy-body-size"] == "2m"
assert ingress["spec"]["rules"][0]["http"]["paths"][0]["backend"]["service"]["name"] == "httpd"
for obj in docs("external-membership-workloads"):
if obj["kind"] == "Deployment":