[council-designer-a] DESIGN.md v1 freeze: §2.1 starter decks + §8 top-heavy target + trendDown -200 (supersedes #18, #21) #23

Merged
claude merged 5 commits from night/council/design-v1-final into night/2026-11-16 2026-11-17 04:21:30 +00:00
Showing only changes of commit 5205201143 - Show all commits
+1 -1
View File
@@ -357,7 +357,7 @@ the last turn's, and every "at scoring" Portal resolves **before** Topics are ju
| Line | Why it isn't dominant |
|---|---|
| All-famous (all max-stat) deck | It becomes an all-cost-5/6 deck with dead early turns. Cheap cards are more efficient **per energy**, expensive cards **per card**. Only 9 cards are seen per match (3 + 6 draws), so both matter. The 1-energy carry-over lets a heavy deck bank energy for a turn-5 six-drop. **sim-balance target: heavy vs curve ≥ 40%.** |
| All-famous (all max-stat) deck | It becomes an all-cost-5/6 deck with dead early turns. Cheap cards are more efficient **per energy**, expensive cards **per card**. Only 9 cards are seen per match (3 + 6 draws), so both matter. An all-cost-5/6 deck is **weak by design**: it has four dead turns (sim-balance interim: 0–15%). There is no hard deck rule in v1; the deck builder warns when a deck has fewer than 4 cards of cost ≤ 2, and every starter deck is curve-shaped (§2.1). **sim-balance target: a top-heavy curve (1/1/2/2/3/3 cards at costs 1–6, as in sim-balance's interim run) vs curve ≥ 40%.** `energyByTurn [2..7]` is a v1.1 candidate. |
| All-cheap flood (cost 1–2) | Weak by design: only 9 slots and 9 cards seen. Critic's sim under these rules: swarm vs curve about 7–11%. Its home is Culture's wide-turn keyword (§10). |
| All one faction | No v1 keyword scales with faction count. `factionSynergyCap` is reserved for modes. Culture, the largest pool, has the weakest keyword (viral). |
| "Always play the highest-power card" | It ignores the on-topic bonus, lane capacity and the hidden Portals. Critic's sim: 18–21% against a smart bot (target < 55%). |