docs/game/DESIGN.md: §8 cite BALANCE.md v1.1 re-run (seat 51.2%, starters 52-53%, owned 42-51%); item 6 noted as v1.2

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-11-17 00:37:58 -05:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 5.5
parent 3c5e8f94ad
commit 09b55b96c3
+2 -2
View File
@@ -375,11 +375,11 @@ the last turn's, and every "at scoring" Portal resolves **before** Topics are ju
| All-famous (all max-stat) deck | It becomes an all-cost-5/6 deck with four dead early turns. Cheap cards are more efficient **per energy**, expensive cards **per card**, and only 9 cards are seen per match (3 + 6 draws). So a pure cost-5/6 deck is **weak by design**: **BALANCE.md v1: 15%**, and no lever (power curve, energy ramp) fixes it without breaking curve or swarm decks. There is no hard deck rule; the deck builder warns below 4 cards of cost ≤ 2, and every starter is curve-shaped (§2.1). **Target met:** a **top-heavy curve** (half the deck at cost 4 or more) wins **57%** (target ≥ 40%). `energyByTurn [2..7]` was rejected for v1.1: it lifts heavy decks but kills swarm (20%). | | All-famous (all max-stat) deck | It becomes an all-cost-5/6 deck with four dead early turns. Cheap cards are more efficient **per energy**, expensive cards **per card**, and only 9 cards are seen per match (3 + 6 draws). So a pure cost-5/6 deck is **weak by design**: **BALANCE.md v1: 15%**, and no lever (power curve, energy ramp) fixes it without breaking curve or swarm decks. There is no hard deck rule; the deck builder warns below 4 cards of cost ≤ 2, and every starter is curve-shaped (§2.1). **Target met:** a **top-heavy curve** (half the deck at cost 4 or more) wins **57%** (target ≥ 40%). `energyByTurn [2..7]` was rejected for v1.1: it lifts heavy decks but kills swarm (20%). |
| All-cheap flood (cost 1–2) | Weak by design: only 9 slots and 9 cards seen. **BALANCE.md v1: 2%** (critic's sim 7–11%). Every lever that revives it breaks curve decks (sweep in BALANCE.md). viral (base +1, v1.1) is its consolation, not its fix. | | All-cheap flood (cost 1–2) | Weak by design: only 9 slots and 9 cards seen. **BALANCE.md v1: 2%** (critic's sim 7–11%). Every lever that revives it breaks curve decks (sweep in BALANCE.md). viral (base +1, v1.1) is its consolation, not its fix. |
| All one faction | No v1 keyword scales with faction count. `factionSynergyCap` is reserved for modes. Culture, the largest pool, splits over three keywords by home stat (§10.1), so it has no single keyword to stack. | | All one faction | No v1 keyword scales with faction count. `factionSynergyCap` is reserved for modes. Culture, the largest pool, splits over three keywords by home stat (§10.1), so it has no single keyword to stack. |
| Owning NFTs buys power (pay-to-win) | Power depends only on cost (§1.3), and cost follows a fixed curve. **BALANCE.md v1.1:** starter decks against each other 45–55%. A realistic owned deck from `card-sample.json` against the four starters: **50 / 40 / 46 / 47%** (Field Guide / Headliners / Pioneers / Stargazers; n ≈ 55, ±13 pp). So owning cards doesn't buy power. Headliners at 40% is watched for v1.2 (lever: `local.amount 2`). | | Owning NFTs buys power (pay-to-win) | Power depends only on cost (§1.3), and cost follows a fixed curve. **BALANCE.md v1.1 re-run (real `RULESET_V1_1`):** each starter deck averages **52–53%** overall. A realistic owned deck from `card-sample.json` wins **42–51%** against the starters (n ≈ 55 per pairing, ±13 pp). So owning cards buys variety, not power. v1.2 levers if owned decks should be a little stronger: `local.amount 2`, and `nostalgic`/`translated` `powerDelta -1` (the two strongest keywords, about +1.65 net per card). |
| "Always play the highest-power card" | It ignores the on-topic bonus, lane capacity and the hidden Portals. **BALANCE.md v1:** the naive max-power line wins **40%** against greedy, and lookahead-lite beats greedy **60–70%**, so skill shows (target < 55%). Critic's sim: 18–21% against a smart bot. | | "Always play the highest-power card" | It ignores the on-topic bonus, lane capacity and the hidden Portals. **BALANCE.md v1:** the naive max-power line wins **40%** against greedy, and lookahead-lite beats greedy **60–70%**, so skill shows (target < 55%). Critic's sim: 18–21% against a smart bot. |
| Stall or pass | Passing leaves lanes to any 1-power card. Two passing players draw. | | Stall or pass | Passing leaves lanes to any 1-power card. Two passing players draw. |
| Mirror the AI | Hidden simultaneous commits: you only see the opponent's cards after you commit. | | Mirror the AI | Hidden simultaneous commits: you only see the opponent's cards after you commit. |
| Seat or initiative | Planning is simultaneous and initiative strictly alternates (each seat has it for 3 of the 6 turns). **BALANCE.md v1.1: first player 51.0% [48.6–53.4]** (target 48–52%; v1 was 53.4%). | | Seat or initiative | Planning is simultaneous and initiative strictly alternates (each seat has it for 3 of the 6 turns). **BALANCE.md v1.1 re-run (real `RULESET_V1_1`): first player 51.2% [48.8–53.6]** (target 48–52%; v1 was 53.4%). |
| Forged or shopped stats | They only raise cost (§1.3), the host check falls back to live stats (§1.10), and trend is capped at ±1. | | Forged or shopped stats | They only raise cost (§1.3), the host check falls back to live stats (§1.10), and trend is capped at ±1. |
| Inflated live pageviews | Worth at most +1, frozen at match start, and only counts for articles with ≥ 20 views a day. | | Inflated live pageviews | Worth at most +1, frozen at match start, and only counts for articles with ≥ 20 views a day. |
| Swinginess | No effect may change a lane by more than 6 power or move cards between lanes in v1 (a keyword-design rule for §10). | | Swinginess | No effect may change a lane by more than 6 power or move cards between lanes in v1 (a keyword-design rule for §10). |