# Visual QA The checklist for a full visual pass (H6). Render everything with `make qa-captures` (about 40 minutes, needs Docker), open every image in `captures/qa/` and judge it against its line here. The contact sheets in `captures/qa/sheets/` are for a first look; open a capture on its own to judge detail. File each defect as a `type/bug` issue. Captures are drawn by Mesa's software renderer in a container. They show what is drawn, not how fast, and colours differ a little from a GPU. The white captions at the top left of the `match_*`, `client_*`, `quality_*` and `hud`/`client_hud*` captures are written by the capture scenarios (Godot's default font) to say what the frame is. They are not part of the game's HUD. ## The last pass: 2026-11-14 82 scenarios and the HUD at 3840x2160 rendered; all were viewed. Two defects were found and fixed: - H15 (#84): a camera placed after the view's last sync kept the murk of where it had been. `match_tide` came out as a flat teal frame, and `match_final` and `match_results` drew dry land in the underwater murk. In the game this was one frame of the wrong murk at every camera cut. - H16 (#85): the terrain grid's square edge showed in the sea from the air, as a pale square round the island in the lobby view. ## Checklist | Area | Captures | What to check | 2026-11-14 | |---|---|---|---| | Menus | `menu_main`, `menu_practice`, `menu_join`, `menu_settings`, `menu_settings_mouse`, `menu_pause`, `menu_results` | Paper panels over the sea and tide post; every label readable; the version line; focus outline on the first button; nothing clipped. | Pass | | Lobby | `match_lobby` | The whole island from the air, sea round it with no square edge. | Pass after H16 | | The drop | `match_ship`, `client_ship`, `match_glide`, `client_glide`, `vessels` | The packet ship and its 24 passengers offshore; the gull-kite held overhead; the island below. | Pass | | Landing | `match_landed`, `client_landed`, `quality_low`, `quality_medium`, `quality_high` | The player on the shoulder camera, a sea chest, a building's inside. The three presets differ in shadow and detail, not in what's there. | Pass | | Biomes | `props_beach`, `props_forest`, `props_highland`, `props_overview`, `props_crate`, `props_felled`, `terrain`, `terrain_lod`, `sea_shore_calm` | Sand with wet patches and beached boats, pine forest, highland stone and boulders, the marsh flats at low tide. | Pass | | Points of interest | `poi_hamlet`, `poi_dock`, `poi_lighthouse`, `poi_quarry`, `poi_salt_works`, `poi_shrine`, `style_*` | Each reads as its place; the woodcut print pass (outlines, hatching) on, and off in the `_plain` captures. | Pass | | Building | `build_fort`, `build_fort_side`, `build_states`, `client_build`, `client_build_refused`, `client_hud_build`, `match_built`, `client_basin` | Every material and state; the ghost green when it can go and red with the reason when it can't; a breakwater basin dry inside at high water. | Pass | | Players and items | `figure_states`, `figure_actions`, `figure_close`, `items_held`, `items_shoulder`, `items_ground`, `items_tiers`, `items_kegs` | Coats in every colour, every pose, items in hand and on the ground, tier marks. | Pass | | Combat | `effects_fight`, `effects_blast`, `effects_work`, `effects_stress` | Muzzle flash at the muzzle, the hit marker round the reticle, the keg blast and collapse dust, tracers in the stress scene. | Pass | | HUD | `client_hud`, `hud_2160` (`CAPTURE_SIZE=3840x2160`) | Tide plaque, health and armour, the six slots, materials, the feed and count, crisp at 4K. | Pass | | Chart | `chart_first`, `chart_later` | Place names, the ship's line, the next tide's land hatched, the minimap. | Pass | | Each tide phase | `sea_tide_0` … `sea_tide_7`, `water_flood`, `water_shore` | The sea rising phase by phase to nothing left; the storm building to a gale with rain; flooding following the terrain. | Pass | | The gale and under water | `sea_shore_gale`, `sea_underwater`, `match_final` | Rain, dark sea and whitecaps; the murk and the bright ceiling only when the camera is under the sea. | Pass after H15 | | Results | `match_tide`, `match_results` | The drowned island from the lobby's viewpoint; the last players on the highest ground. | Pass after H15 | | Camera tests | `camera`, `camera_aim`, `camera_wall`, `canopy`, `canopy_before` | Test cards for the camera rig, drawn with plain shapes on purpose; check the framing, not the art. | Pass | | Terrain tests | `terrain_cracks`, `terrain_cracks_control` | Magenta shows through gaps: the control must crack and the real terrain must not. | Pass | ## Placeholders Nothing the game draws is a stand-in. `test_world_art` fails on any primitive mesh or placeholder resource under `src/` or `assets/`. The plain shapes in the `camera*` scenarios are test cards under `test/capture/`, which isn't shipped.