24 KiB
WikiDeck: Edit War — balance report
Owner: sim-balance (claude/wikideck#4). Harness: shared/bots/, scripts/sim/ (PR #14).
Report v1: 2026-11-17 00:45 EST
Engine: night/2026-11-16 @ 482de6c/4a4941c (engine #25 and #27, keywords and Portals; card data #28).
Bots: view-only (viewFor); see Method.
Card pool: docs/game/card-sample.json (236 cards), derived per §1 with percentiles from the sample.
Decks: the 4 §2.1 starter decks, 4 "realistic owned" decks (12 random cards from the sample), and archetypes.
Runs:
- full field: 3,000 matches per ruleset (report mix, 4 workers; r350 is memory-limited tonight)
- focused starters + owned round robin: 2,000 matches per ruleset
- greedy lever sweeps: 2,000–3,000 per variant
v1.1 re-run on the real engine hooks (00:31)
Engine: night/engine/v1-1 @ 4a0dbd0, with RULESET_V1_1 (DESIGN #32): viral {base 1, cap 3}, encyclopedic {sides 1}, rising.powerDelta -1, cultureKeyword: home, costThresholds [26,39,51,63,78]. It is the same focused run as above: the §2.1 starters plus 4 owned decks (cost thresholds and Culture keyword per v1.1), 2,000 matches per ruleset.
| v1 | v1.1 (#32, exact) | v1.1 + item 6 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| starter deck WR, overall (FG / Head / Pio / Star) | 65 / 40 / 57 / 54 | 52 / 52 / 52 / 53 ✅ | 50 / 56 / 50 / 52 |
| starter pairings, min–max | 23–77% | 39–61% (only FG–Head 61%, n = 51, is outside 45–55) | 42–58% |
| owned vs starters (FG / Head / Pio / Star) | 37 / 54 / 40 / 41 | 51 / 42 / 47 / 43 | 51 / 41 / 46 / 48 |
| first player | 53.4% | 51.2% [48.8–53.6] ✅ | 51.0% [48.6–53.5] |
| decided in the first third | 4.1% | 3.3% | 4.1% |
| greedy > maxpower, lookahead-lite > greedy | 62%, 60% | 63%, 65% | 51%, 70% |
Net keyword value per card under the exact v1.1 (counterfactual trigger value plus powerDelta):
| keyword | v1.1 net per card |
|---|---|
| translated | +1.64 |
| nostalgic | +1.69 |
| viral | +1.15 (base included) |
| encyclopedic | +0.77 |
| rising | 1.71 − 1 = +0.71 |
| local | +0.69 |
My earlier flat-+1 stand-in for encyclopedic overstated it: the real hook is worth +0.77, not +1.23.
Updated recommendation:
- Ship #32 (v1.1) as it is. Every starter's overall WR is 52–53% and first player is 51.2%. The one out-of-band pairing (FG vs Headliners at 61%) is within this run's noise.
- Item 6 is an optional v1.2 candidate.
nostalgicandtranslatedatpowerDelta -1would bring translated and nostalgic (about +1.65) in line with the others (0.7–1.15). It fixes FG vs Headliners (50%), but at n ≈ 55 per pairing it isn't clearly better overall (42–58% vs 39–61%). Decide it on a larger run. - Owned vs starters is 42–51%: roughly the variety-not-power goal, slightly weak against Headliners and Stargazers.
Raw tables:
v1.1: 2000 matches, 10 draws, 0 engine errors
- First player (turn-1 initiative), symmetric games: 51.2% [48.8–53.6] (n=1641)
- Decided early: 3.3% of decisive games locked in during the first third, 12.1% by half-time
- Skill: greedy>maxpower 63.3% (n=147), lookahead-lite>greedy 64.6% (n=99), greedy>random 83.5% (n=103)
| starters (row vs col) | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | vs all decks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| field-guide | – | 61% (n=51) | 49% (n=53) | 56% (n=55) | 51.8% |
| headliners | 39% (n=51) | – | 44% (n=54) | 50% (n=54) | 52.1% |
| pioneers | 51% (n=53) | 56% (n=54) | – | 48% (n=58) | 52.3% |
| stargazers | 44% (n=55) | 50% (n=54) | 52% (n=58) | – | 53.2% |
| owned (random 12 from card-sample) vs | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| owned-0 | 39% | 32% | 41% | 46% | 40.3% |
| owned-1 | 50% | 43% | 42% | 38% | 45.1% |
| owned-2 | 55% | 37% | 62% | 44% | 49.7% |
| owned-3 | 62% | 55% | 43% | 45% | 55.0% |
| all owned | 51% (n=233) | 42% (n=196) | 47% (n=198) | 43% (n=198) |
| keyword | power per card | games decided by it | cards played |
|---|---|---|---|
| rising | +1.71 | 13.3% | 1503 |
| nostalgic | +1.69 | 13.4% | 1791 |
| translated | +1.64 | 17.8% | 4976 |
| viral | +1.15 | 7.3% | 1852 |
| encyclopedic | +0.77 | 6.2% | 2349 |
| local | +0.69 | 6.4% | 4052 |
v1.1+item6: 2000 matches, 9 draws, 0 engine errors
- First player (turn-1 initiative), symmetric games: 51.0% [48.6–53.5] (n=1640)
- Decided early: 4.1% of decisive games locked in during the first third, 12.6% by half-time
- Skill: greedy>maxpower 51.0% (n=147), lookahead-lite>greedy 70.0% (n=100), greedy>random 82.7% (n=104)
| starters (row vs col) | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | vs all decks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| field-guide | – | 50% (n=52) | 50% (n=52) | 53% (n=55) | 49.7% |
| headliners | 50% (n=52) | – | 58% (n=55) | 48% (n=54) | 56.1% |
| pioneers | 50% (n=52) | 42% (n=55) | – | 42% (n=57) | 49.7% |
| stargazers | 47% (n=55) | 52% (n=54) | 58% (n=57) | – | 51.9% |
| owned (random 12 from card-sample) vs | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| owned-0 | 48% | 41% | 50% | 39% | 47.1% |
| owned-1 | 41% | 44% | 47% | 52% | 47.2% |
| owned-2 | 57% | 36% | 38% | 51% | 48.8% |
| owned-3 | 60% | 41% | 49% | 49% | 49.4% |
| all owned | 51% (n=233) | 41% (n=197) | 46% (n=200) | 48% (n=198) |
| keyword | power per card | games decided by it | cards played |
|---|---|---|---|
| rising | +1.72 | 14.2% | 1546 |
| translated | +1.69 | 17.0% | 4787 |
| nostalgic | +1.68 | 13.2% | 1709 |
| viral | +1.15 | 8.8% | 1924 |
| encyclopedic | +0.79 | 6.7% | 2403 |
| local | +0.70 | 6.7% | 4127 |
TL;DR for the council (report v1, 00:25; see the v1.1 re-run above for the updated recommendation)
-
Seat and initiative are fine: 51.5% [49.6–53.5] for the turn-1 initiative holder (n = 2,421 symmetric games), and seat 0 51.2%. Draws are 0.4%. The tie-break (total power) decides 4.7% of games. This full-field run started before the bot-side queue-count fix (PR #14); the effect is at most a 0.02 nudge to the heuristic. The focused starters run, after the fix, gives a borderline 53.4% [51.0–55.8] under v1 and 51.0% [48.6–53.4] under the recommended v1.1. Initiative only matters through reveal order, and v1.1 removes most of the order-sensitive power.
-
Keyword values are lopsided, confirming the critic's figures within 0.2:
keyword power per card rising +1.76 translated +1.53 nostalgic +1.45 local +0.65 viral +0.19 encyclopedic +0.19 Values are counterfactual replays. viral and encyclopedic are dead: raising viral to amount 2 / cap 3 only reached +0.24, and encyclopedic amount 3 only +0.33. Their conditions are the problem, not their numbers.
-
The starter decks are not 45–55% in v1: pairings run 23–77%. Field Guide (rising + nostalgic) wins 65% overall and Headliners (local + viral) 40%. With v1.1 items 1–6, every pairing is 45–55%.
-
Owned decks lose to the starters, because they are about 51% viral and squashed into cost 2–4. That is the wrong way round for "NFTs give variety, not power".
-
costThresholdssquash fame. The owned cost mix is 3/23/37/22/10/5.[26,39,51,63,78]gives 13/20/22/20/15/10, which hits the target and confirms the critic and designer-a. -
Pure extremes are dead under every lever: heavy (cost 5–6 only) at 15%, swarm (cost ≤ 2) at 2%. Top-heavy (curve 1/1/2/2/3/3) is 57%, so the §8 top-heavy retarget (≥ 40%) passes. Swarm and heavy aren't fixable without breaking curve decks: every lever that helps one hurts the other (sweep below). Treat them as non-decks.
-
Matches are always 6 turns. Only 6.5% of decisive games are decided in the first third, and 19.9% by half-time, so most games stay live to the end.
-
Skill expression is healthy:
- greedy beats maxpower ("always play the biggest card") 59.5%. §8 wants the naive line under 55% against a smart bot; it is at 40.5%.
- lookahead-lite beats greedy 63.7%.
- greedy beats random 77.5%.
Proposed v1.1 rule changes (concrete)
| # | Change | Evidence | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | costThresholds: [26, 39, 51, 63, 78] (designer-a's quantile rule) |
owned cost mix 3/23/37/22/10/5 → 13/20/22/20/15/10 | adopt |
| 2 | rising.powerDelta: -1 |
rising +1.76 per card, the top keyword | adopt |
| 3 | viral: "+1, plus +1 per earlier reveal this turn, max +3" (critic) | viral +0.19; buffing amount/cap alone gives +0.24 | adopt. It needs the base +1. |
| 4 | encyclopedic: "+2 if you have no other cards here" (critic) | +0.19; amount 3 alone gives +0.33 | adopt. It needs the condition change. |
| 5 | Culture takes its home-stat keyword (critic) | owned decks drop from 51% viral to 18% | see the v1.1 results |
| 6 | nostalgic.powerDelta -1, translated.powerDelta -1 |
+1.45 / +1.53 per card, close to rising. Without them Field Guide beats Headliners 60% under 1–5 (approximated hooks). | optional, v1.2: see the v1.1 re-run above |
| 7 | No change for heavy or swarm | no lever fixes both | – |
| 8 | No change for seat or initiative | 48–52% target met | – |
Starter round robin and owned vs starters (focused run: §2.1 starters plus 4 owned decks, 2,000 matches per ruleset)
| v1 | v1.1 critic package (1–5) | v1.1 critic + item 6 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| starter pairings, min–max | 23–77% | 40–60% | 45–55% ✅ |
| starter deck WR (FG / Head / Pio / Star) | 65 / 40 / 57 / 54 | 50 / 48 / 54 / 54 | 51 / 55 / 52 / 52 |
| owned vs starters (FG / Head / Pio / Star) | 37 / 54 / 40 / 41 | 52 / 45 / 46 / 43 | 50 / 40 / 46 / 47 |
| first player (turn-1 initiative) | 53.4% [51.0–55.8] | 52.5% [50.1–54.9] | 51.0% [48.6–53.4] ✅ |
| lookahead-lite > greedy | 60% | 70% | 66% |
Each starter pairing has about 50–58 symmetric games (±13 pp at 95%). Each owned-vs-starter cell has about 200 games (±7 pp).
Net keyword value under v1.1 (counterfactual trigger value per card, plus powerDelta), from the 3,000-match critic-package full field:
| keyword | v1.1 net per card |
|---|---|
| rising | 1.74 − 1 = +0.74 |
| viral | 0.16 + 1 = +1.16 |
| encyclopedic | ≈ 0.23 + 1 = +1.23 (approximated) |
| translated | +1.59, or +0.59 with item 6 |
| nostalgic | +1.58, or +0.58 with item 6 |
| local | +0.66 |
So every keyword lands within 0.6–1.2. This matches the critic's numbers (viral +1.15, encyclopedic +0.9, rising +0.9) to within 0.35.
Recommendation: ship items 1–5 plus item 6 (nostalgic.powerDelta -1, translated.powerDelta -1). Without item 6, Field Guide still beats Headliners 60% and Headliners sits at 40–41% against every starter. With it, every pairing is inside 45–55. Owned decks then win 40–50% against the starters: the variety-not-power goal, slightly on the weak side. If v1.2 wants owned decks a bit stronger, the next lever is local.amount 2 (Headliners and owned decks are about 25% local).
Raw tables:
v1 (DEFAULT_RULESET), focused: 2000 matches, 9 draws, 0 engine errors
- First player (turn-1 initiative), symmetric games: 53.4% [51.0–55.8] (n=1641)
- Decided early: 4.1% of decisive games locked in during the first third, 15.5% by half-time
- Skill: greedy>maxpower 61.6% (n=146), lookahead-lite>greedy 60.0% (n=100), greedy>random 81.7% (n=104)
| starters (row vs col) | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | vs all decks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| field-guide | – | 77% (n=52) | 57% (n=53) | 69% (n=54) | 64.8% |
| headliners | 23% (n=52) | – | 36% (n=56) | 35% (n=54) | 39.6% |
| pioneers | 43% (n=53) | 64% (n=56) | – | 52% (n=58) | 56.9% |
| stargazers | 31% (n=54) | 65% (n=54) | 48% (n=58) | – | 54.3% |
| owned (random 12 from card-sample) vs | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| owned-0 | 42% | 48% | 35% | 37% | 40.0% |
| owned-1 | 26% | 62% | 40% | 45% | 47.4% |
| owned-2 | 45% | 57% | 44% | 43% | 52.7% |
| owned-3 | 35% | 47% | 40% | 37% | 42.3% |
| all owned | 37% (n=233) | 54% (n=197) | 40% (n=200) | 41% (n=197) |
| keyword | power per card | games decided by it | cards played |
|---|---|---|---|
| rising | +1.75 | 12.0% | 1822 |
| translated | +1.55 | 18.6% | 2263 |
| nostalgic | +1.54 | 10.3% | 2197 |
| local | +0.71 | 6.2% | 4300 |
| viral | +0.22 | 3.3% | 6034 |
| encyclopedic | +0.17 | 0.8% | 1042 |
v1.1-critic: 2000 matches, 4 draws, 0 engine errors
- First player (turn-1 initiative), symmetric games: 52.5% [50.1–54.9] (n=1646)
- Decided early: 3.5% of decisive games locked in during the first third, 11.4% by half-time
- Skill: greedy>maxpower 59.6% (n=146), lookahead-lite>greedy 70.0% (n=100), greedy>random 80.8% (n=104)
| starters (row vs col) | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | vs all decks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| field-guide | – | 60% (n=52) | 51% (n=53) | 51% (n=55) | 50.1% |
| headliners | 40% (n=52) | – | 41% (n=56) | 41% (n=54) | 48.3% |
| pioneers | 49% (n=53) | 59% (n=56) | – | 55% (n=58) | 54.2% |
| stargazers | 49% (n=55) | 59% (n=54) | 45% (n=58) | – | 54.1% |
| owned (random 12 from card-sample) vs | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| owned-0 | 46% | 43% | 46% | 49% | 43.8% |
| owned-1 | 50% | 43% | 40% | 34% | 44.1% |
| owned-2 | 52% | 47% | 56% | 51% | 52.7% |
| owned-3 | 63% | 49% | 43% | 42% | 52.4% |
| all owned | 52% (n=233) | 45% (n=198) | 46% (n=198) | 43% (n=199) |
| keyword | power per card | games decided by it | cards played |
|---|---|---|---|
| rising | +1.71 | 12.8% | 1505 |
| nostalgic | +1.68 | 13.6% | 1789 |
| translated | +1.64 | 17.6% | 4491 |
| local | +0.70 | 6.3% | 4081 |
| encyclopedic | +0.21 | 1.7% | 2177 |
| viral | +0.13 | 0.9% | 2524 |
v1.1-critic-nerf: 2000 matches, 14 draws, 0 engine errors
- First player (turn-1 initiative), symmetric games: 51.0% [48.6–53.4] (n=1636)
- Decided early: 4.0% of decisive games locked in during the first third, 12.7% by half-time
- Skill: greedy>maxpower 58.2% (n=146), lookahead-lite>greedy 66.0% (n=100), greedy>random 79.8% (n=104)
| starters (row vs col) | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | vs all decks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| field-guide | – | 49% (n=51) | 50% (n=52) | 55% (n=55) | 50.6% |
| headliners | 51% (n=51) | – | 50% (n=54) | 46% (n=54) | 55.3% |
| pioneers | 50% (n=52) | 50% (n=54) | – | 47% (n=58) | 51.8% |
| stargazers | 45% (n=55) | 54% (n=54) | 53% (n=58) | – | 51.9% |
| owned (random 12 from card-sample) vs | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| owned-0 | 51% | 43% | 52% | 46% | 46.0% |
| owned-1 | 40% | 35% | 47% | 33% | 43.1% |
| owned-2 | 52% | 42% | 37% | 56% | 51.1% |
| owned-3 | 58% | 38% | 47% | 55% | 50.1% |
| all owned | 50% (n=231) | 40% (n=197) | 46% (n=199) | 47% (n=197) |
| keyword | power per card | games decided by it | cards played |
|---|---|---|---|
| rising | +1.72 | 15.6% | 1534 |
| translated | +1.69 | 16.3% | 4315 |
| nostalgic | +1.66 | 13.3% | 1686 |
| local | +0.71 | 6.4% | 4113 |
| encyclopedic | +0.21 | 1.8% | 2221 |
| viral | +0.13 | 0.7% | 2571 |
Critic package, full field (3,000 matches)
v1.1-critic: 3000 matches, 14 draws, 0 engine errors
- First player (turn-1 initiative), symmetric games: 49.7% [47.7–51.7] (n=2418)
- Decided early: 8.0% of decisive games locked in during the first third, 17.9% by half-time
- Skill: greedy>maxpower 54.6% (n=238), lookahead-lite>greedy 62.7% (n=161), greedy>random 84.0% (n=169)
| starters (row vs col) | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | vs all decks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| field-guide | – | 38% (n=8) | 50% (n=8) | 29% (n=7) | 60.6% |
| headliners | 62% (n=8) | – | 36% (n=11) | 56% (n=9) | 46.8% |
| pioneers | 50% (n=8) | 64% (n=11) | – | 50% (n=12) | 59.7% |
| stargazers | 71% (n=7) | 44% (n=9) | 50% (n=12) | – | 64.8% |
| owned (random 12 from card-sample) vs | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| owned-0 | 33% | 64% | 36% | 50% | 55.3% |
| owned-1 | 50% | 50% | 33% | 43% | 54.9% |
| owned-2 | 55% | 58% | 27% | 42% | 52.7% |
| owned-3 | 11% | 42% | 9% | 50% | 52.8% |
| all owned | 38% (n=37) | 54% (n=41) | 26% (n=39) | 46% (n=37) |
| archetype | WR vs other decks |
|---|---|
| curve | 58.6% [51.7–65.2] (n=203) |
| top-heavy | 52.2% [45.4–58.9] (n=205) |
| heavy | 23.4% [18.1–29.7] (n=205) |
| swarm | 0.9% [0.2–3.3] (n=220) |
| mono-Culture | 55.4% [48.9–61.6] (n=233) |
| mono-People | 47.5% [41.0–54.1] (n=221) |
| mono-Nature | 40.3% [34.0–46.9] (n=216) |
| keyword | power per card | games decided by it | cards played |
|---|---|---|---|
| rising | +1.74 | 21.1% | 3184 |
| translated | +1.59 | 15.8% | 3450 |
| nostalgic | +1.58 | 19.7% | 2871 |
| local | +0.66 | 7.5% | 4696 |
| encyclopedic | +0.23 | 2.0% | 4548 |
| viral | +0.16 | 1.5% | 4733 |
v1 full-field detail
v1 (DEFAULT_RULESET): 3000 matches, 13 draws, 0 engine errors
- First player (turn-1 initiative), symmetric games: 51.5% [49.6–53.5] (n=2421)
- Decided early: 6.5% of decisive games locked in during the first third, 19.9% by half-time
- Skill: greedy>maxpower 59.5% (n=237), lookahead-lite>greedy 63.7% (n=160), greedy>random 77.5% (n=169)
| starters (row vs col) | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | vs all decks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| field-guide | – | 70% (n=10) | 57% (n=7) | 83% (n=6) | 67.4% |
| headliners | 30% (n=10) | – | 33% (n=12) | 56% (n=9) | 51.7% |
| pioneers | 43% (n=7) | 67% (n=12) | – | 64% (n=14) | 67.0% |
| stargazers | 17% (n=6) | 44% (n=9) | 36% (n=14) | – | 53.3% |
| owned (random 12 from card-sample) vs | field-guide | headliners | pioneers | stargazers | all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| owned-0 | 29% | 40% | 15% | 58% | 51.0% |
| owned-1 | 33% | 33% | 67% | 56% | 51.6% |
| owned-2 | 27% | 62% | 62% | 25% | 59.7% |
| owned-3 | 43% | 50% | 56% | 70% | 57.7% |
| all owned | 31% (n=42) | 48% (n=48) | 44% (n=36) | 51% (n=43) |
| archetype | WR vs other decks |
|---|---|
| curve | 50.0% [43.5–56.5] (n=222) |
| top-heavy | 56.8% [50.2–63.1] (n=222) |
| heavy | 15.3% [11.0–20.9] (n=203) |
| swarm | 2.0% [0.9–4.6] (n=250) |
| mono-Culture | 42.2% [35.7–48.9] (n=211) |
| mono-People | 51.7% [44.9–58.4] (n=207) |
| mono-Nature | 56.0% [49.6–62.3] (n=232) |
| keyword | power per card | games decided by it | cards played |
|---|---|---|---|
| rising | +1.76 | 15.6% | 4027 |
| translated | +1.53 | 17.5% | 1266 |
| nostalgic | +1.45 | 16.4% | 3610 |
| local | +0.65 | 6.1% | 6781 |
| viral | +0.19 | 2.3% | 8030 |
| encyclopedic | +0.19 | 1.4% | 1002 |
Starter-vs-starter cells here have small n; the focused round robin above has the real numbers. Keyword table: counterfactual trigger value per card (excluding any powerDelta).
Lever sweeps (greedy mirrors, real pool)
Before keywords were implemented (engine core @ c938407), I swept these levers. Each row is 3,000 greedy-mirror games. Columns are win rate vs the other decks.
| variant | heavy | swarm | curve | first player |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| v1 | 11.9% | 0.9% | 64.5% | 50.5% |
energyCarryMax 2 |
17.8% | 0.9% | 59.3% | 51.0% |
energyByTurn [2..7] |
42.4% | 0.0% | 41.3% | 49.7% |
powerByCost [0,2,3,4,6,8,10] |
8.1% | 13.4% | 65.6% | 49.3% |
powerByCost [0,2,4,5,7,8,10] |
0.3% | 36.1% | 62.1% | 49.7% |
laneCapacity 4 |
10.3% | 0.6% | 63.6% | 50.7% |
onTopicBonus [0,2,2,2,2,3,3] |
10.2% | 6.8% | 62.2% | 49.7% |
Reading: energy 2→7 rescues heavy but kills swarm and curve, and flatter power rescues swarm but kills heavy. Neither helps the normal decks. Keep v1's curve.
Caveats
-
Bots aren't people. Greedy doesn't plan energy carry and queues one card at a time; lookahead-lite is shallow.
-
Hidden cards in determinizations are sampled from the loaner pool, not from the opponent's real decklist.
-
Some critic-package items need engine hooks that don't exist yet, so this run approximates them:
item modelled as exact? viral base +1 powerDelta +1yes encyclopedic "your side only" powerDelta +1, about the critic's measured +0.9no: an approximation until engine-b adds encyclopedic {sides 1}powerDelta > 0is a sim stand-in: the engine's derivation clampspowerDeltato [−3, 0]. -
Owned decks are 4 random 12-card draws, not curated. They have no curve fill, so some are lopsided.
Method
Engine. Every match runs on the real rules engine (shared/game, public index.ts API only), through
shared/bots/game-adapter.ts. Nothing in the sim re-implements rules. The engine commit is named in each
results section.
Bots (shared/bots/index.ts, each a pure (state, player, rng) => action):
random: a uniformly random legal play or commit.maxpower: always queues the highest printed-power card it can afford, in a random legal lane. This is the DESIGN §8 "always play the highest-power card" line.greedy: one-ply. It takes the action whose result scores best on a lane heuristic: a soft lead per Topic plus total power. The heuristic sees the bot's own queued plays and the opponent's revealed cards only.lookahead-lite/lookahead: flat Monte Carlo over the top 3–4 greedy candidates, with 4–8 rollouts each. Before each rollout, the opponent's queued plays are taken back and its hand and deck reshuffled (determinization), so the bot never reads hidden information.
Seats. Plans are simultaneous: seat 0 queues and commits, then seat 1. Neither bot can see the other's queue, so the order leaks nothing. "First player" means the seat with initiative on turn 1.
Schedule. Per ruleset, matches are drawn from a fixed mix of bot pairings with random seats:
| pairing | share | used for |
|---|---|---|
| greedy vs greedy | 55% | balance (decks, cards, keywords, first player) |
| lookahead-lite vs lookahead-lite | 12% | balance with a stronger player |
| random vs random | 5% | baseline |
| greedy vs lookahead-lite, maxpower vs lookahead-lite, maxpower vs greedy, random vs greedy | 28% | skill expression |
Deck, card and keyword statistics use only bot-symmetric games (the same bot on both seats). Deck pairs are
drawn uniformly, mirrors included; the per-deck win rate excludes mirrors. --mix fast (greedy only) is used for
quick lever sweeps.
Decks. These are built from a card pool by defaultDecks():
- 6 seeded starter decks (
starterDeck) curve(cost counts 2/3/3/2/1/1)top-heavy(1/1/2/2/3/3)heavy(cost 5–6 first: the §8 "all-famous" line)swarm(cost ≤ 2 first)mono-<faction>curve decks for factions with ≥ 6 cardskw-<keyword>curve decks for keywords on ≥ 3 cards
The pool is the engine's preview pool, or council-data's card-sample.json derived per DESIGN §1
(percentile → fame → cost, home stat, faction keyword). Loaner power always follows the ruleset's
powerByCost.
Metrics.
- Win rates with Wilson 95% intervals. ↑/↓ marks an interval that excludes 50%.
- First-player WR: initiative holder on turn 1, symmetric games.
- Match length in turns.
- "Decided early": the turn from which the eventual winner led on the heuristic until the end, as a fraction of the match.
- Per-card WR: the win rate of the side that played the card.
- Per-stat correlations.
- Keyword value: a counterfactual. Each finished match is replayed with the same actions and the keyword
removed from one side. We report the side's lost total power per keyword card, and how often removing the
keyword made the result worse for that side ("games decided by it"). DESIGN §10.1 asks for
keywordParams.<id>.powerDeltawhen a keyword is worth more than about 1 power.
Reproduce.
SIM_POOL=docs/game/card-sample.json SIM_RULESETS=scripts/sim/variants/v1.json \
npx tsx scripts/sim/run.ts --engine game --matches 5000 --workers 10 --out sim-out
python3 scripts/sim/summary.py sim-out
Limits.
- Bots are not humans. Greedy undervalues saving energy and bluffing.
- Lookahead rollouts are short.
- Deck archetypes are built automatically, not tuned by hand.
- The 100-card sample is skewed: Culture 53, People 30, Nature 9, History 5, Science 3, Space 0.